The On Deck Circle

The unofficial home of Real Talk

Underrated Players in the NHL: Just the Start of a Much Longer List

Posted by Blake Murphy on March 17, 2021

This article has been submitted by Ian Cass.

Sydney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin will be the face of the NHL for years to come. These guys are serious game breakers. But I’m not here to talk about them. Even though they deserve every lick of praise they get, they certainly get enough of it in the hockey world. On the other hand, there are too many NHL players who don’t get the credit they deserve. In a game that is often too fixated on numbers, there are a lot of impact players out there who go relatively unnoticed. Even though I don’t like the term “underrated” because it leaves too much open for interpretation, I’m going to throw it out there regardless. These guys are underrated, and it is about time that they started getting a piece of the limelight.

I’m limiting the list to six since I could go on all day with this. You may disagree with some of my selections so please, feel free to let me know and also add players to the list! I’m just getting it started.

1. Marc Savard
Why does nobody talk about Marc Savard? Since the 2005-2006 season, only Joe Thornton has racked up more assists. Currently, Savard sits atop the the NHL in the category. Just to put it in better perspective, here are some of the guys that are looking up at him: Thrornton, Datsyuk, Malkin, Spezza, Lecavalier, Richards, Lidstrom, and St. Louis. How many times have you heard the name Marc Savard used in the same breath as these guys? I’d say never. Just because Savard doesn’t put the puck in the net with the same efficiency, it doesn’t make him any less valuable. He is currently tied for 11th in league scoring with Mats Sundin. That’s ahead of St. Louis, Gaborik, Stall, Getzlaf, Crosby (Ok, that’s a stretch), the Sedin twins, Richards, and Briere to name a few notables. When it came time for Gretzky and boys to make up the Olympic team, not once did anyone give Savard a moment’s thought. He is one of the best playmaking forwards in the game today. He is also one of the only reasons that the underdog Boston Bruins seem to have a firm grasp on a playoff spot. Give Savard some credit - it’s long overdue.


2. Duncan Keith
Duncan Keith is a great defenseman on a weak Blackhawks team (weak for now, but look out in a few years). Sure, he got some well-deserved credit earlier this year when he was named to his first all-star team, but he is another example of a relatively unknown player who deserves to be talked about with the best young defensemen in the game. It took people a while to realize how incredible a player Brian Campbell is and it’s only a matter of time before Keith is in the same category. Like Campbell, at just under six feet he’s fairly small as far as top defensemen go. In the new NHL, though, fast and mobile defenseman who can move the puck and skate with the top opposing forwards are crucial to a team’s success. If I haven’t convinced you, here’s is where it starts to get good. Keith is currently plus 27. That is sixth in the NHL! I have always said that plus minus is the most telling stat for a defenseman, especially on a weak team, but usually you can only compare plus minuses with teammates. On a team that is third from the bottom in the Western Conference, he trails only Lidstrom, Datsyuk, Heatley, Zetterberg and Iginla in the category. You have to go all the way down to number 22 to find the next best plus minus for a player on a non-playoff team (who happens to be equally underrated teammate Patrick Sharp). When this young Chicago team starts to light it up in a few years, look for Keith to make a name for himself among the best defensemen in the game.

3. Ryan Malone
On a team with Sydney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Marian Hossa, it is easy to see why some of the other players may fly under the radar. When Crosby went down, Malkin was given almost all of the credit for keeping the Pens in serious contention in the East. Malkin was incredible during that streak, but there was a guy at his side the entire way that never got any recognition: Ryan Malone. He played some seriously good hockey while Crosby was out of the lineup. He’s scored 24 goals and has averaged a point a game since Sid went down in mid January. If the Pens make a serious playoff run, Malone will be a big part of it.


4. Jay Pandolfo
Defensive forwards are the most commonly underrated players. They aren’t always fun to watch, but they become prized deep into the playoffs. Pandolfo is one of the best examples of a player who never gets enough credit. Him and longtime line-mate John Madden are the definition of the Selke Trophy. Madden won the award back in 2001 but Pandolfo, who has only received one lame nomination for the award, has never been given the credit he deserves. He is one of the best penalty killers in the game, consistently shuts down the best forwards in the NHL, and played all 82 games for the Devils in three consecutive seasons from 2004-2007. Give the guy the Selke. It might as well be his name.

5. Jason Pominville
Since the Sabres began a semi-rebuilding process, Pominville (along with teammate Derek Roy, who could easily be on this list), has done all he can to keep the Sabers in the playoff race. I bet you didn’t know that Jason Pominville is the captain of the Sabres. He has 22 goals and 65 points, putting him in a tie for 28th in league scoring with Daniel Sedin and Brendan Morrow. He plays in all situations and is clearly shaping up to be a great leader in this league.

Getzlaf
6. Ryan Getzlaf
This is the reason I don’t like the term underrated. Getzlaf is very highly rated. But he’s on the list because I don’t think he gets the credit he deserves. Getzlaf is flat out one of the best players in the league, no questions asked. He is the best forward and the leading scorer on the best team in the NHL. He is a big physical body, a great skater, he scores, he passes, he plays defense, he kills penalties, he plays the power play, and he’s only getting better. He made a big impact during Canada’s victory in the 2005 World Juniors, he’s already won a cup, and he’s going to win more. More of everything. Crosby, Ovechkin, Malkin, Getzlaf. He’s right there with the best young players in the game. This guy is a star.

Here are some honourable mentions:
Patrick Sharp
Derek Roy
Joe Pavelski (or the entire Sharks’ second line)
Jere Lehtinen
Tomas Plekanec
Mark Streit
Antoine Vermette
Ray Whitney

This article has been submitted by Ian Cass.

7 Responses to “Underrated Players in the NHL: Just the Start of a Much Longer List”

  1. slutbanger69 Says:

    ray whitney should be there, he’s the man… also corey stillman should get some mention and plecs is a rising star, wouldn’t call him underrated, just young

  2. paul Says:

    great list, i’d include pascal leclaire (why does he got no love???) and kris draper… HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH not

  3. Stu P S Says:

    Ryan Malone is awesome, and he’ll always answer the bell when Malkin and Sid get assaulted. Plus he’s originally from the Burgh.

    Also, Marc Savard is underrated by everyone except Don Cherry.

    I’d also like to throw Corey Perry into the mix, another key cog in the Ducks machine.

  4. Blake Murphy Says:

    I’d like to throw my own name out there. I was not a strong skater but I had unbelievable vision and was consistently in the race for the scoring title, but didn’t really get any love.

    Savard is the man.

  5. kevin Says:

    great article - you are right, we could go on all day with this one. just to challenge you for a second though, have you heard the classic exchange, question: “who’s the best player on the worst team?” answer: “no one cares.” not so much in today’s world of stat-hacking religious zealots and what not but that’s what’s wrong with keith. he plays in obscurity on a team that has a bright future but does nothing for anyone now, not to mention being burried under the likes of kane and the havlat soap opera. keith is appreciated by fans like you and i; call it underrated or whatever you like, but he’s gonna play that roll until people fear the hawks (re: 3-4 years down the road).

    and what’s this about pandolfo? “Defensive forwards are the most commonly underrated players.” no they’re not, they are just the players fans talk about the least because they play the unseen part of the game. well, maybe in that sense i agree with you wholeheartedly then, but they aren’t underpayed anymore! just look at mr. gomez himself rocking out in manhattan.

    and pauly? “kris draper… HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH not” that’s just one too many “HA’s” for my liking there buddy. two words: team canada. two more: gold medal. just as much of a part of the sweet salt lake victory as anyone (not to mention a few stanley cup teams) is kris “daywalker” draper. i wouldn’t call him underrated if you paid me, and i’m tempted to hunt you down, climb a thirty foot latter so we can see eye to eye and tell you how disappointed i am. but i guess this will suffice.

    anyways great article, hope other people share their thoughts.

  6. glenn jackson Says:

    Hello Blake,

    I agree with your list. I was wondering what you thought about a gentlemen named Trevor Daley on the Dallas Stars. What do you think his potential is for the future in Dallas and the league?

  7. Blake Murphy Says:

    Hey Glenn—Ian’s article, but I’m sure he’ll be glad you agree.

    As for Daley, he’s taken a while to ‘make it’ from a statistical perspective, but he’s still only 24 and has lots of time to develop. Defensively, I can’t really judge, though he’s had a small plus/minus deficit on a good team. I know he was the victim of Van-Beezer’s racism in Junior, so it’d make for a good ‘facing adversity’ story if he made it big, though he can obviously offer more than that.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>